Updated Thursday, July 24, 2014 as of 11:40 PM ET
Blogs - The Web-Savvy Advisor
Social Media Policies: Employee Challenges Pose Legal Risk
Wednesday, November 27, 2013
Partner Insights

Challenges to social media protocols by employees fired for violating them are succeeding with increasing frequency.

To mitigate the risks of costly legal proceedings and damage to company morale and reputation, financial advisory firms drafting social media policies should make sure the process is a holistic endeavor that involves human resources, marketing and legal departments.

Beware: Good intentions in creating such policies, like protecting against disclosure of confidential information, harassment and public disparagement of the company, may, and often do, result in employee challenges.

Specifically, disparagement of and insults directed to co-workers, supervisors and the company in social media may be protected if the company’s prohibition is worded too broadly.

Indeed, workplace social media is a conundrum for compliance and risk personnel because it pits the needs to protect the company and its work force against federal laws that protect the rights of workers to comment about working conditions and to organize to do something about them.

Lafe Solomon, former General Counsel of the National Labor Relations Board, has called social media “the 21st century water cooler.” In ancient times, perhaps ten years ago, employees gathered around the office water cooler to exchange ideas, gossip and complaints about the company, co-workers and supervisors. But those comments rarely left the four walls of the office.

In the digital age, Facebook, Twitter and other sites permit such statements to be generated publicly, to a potential audience of millions. Accordingly, it would seem to be consistent with common sense to prohibit disparagement of the company and supervisors in social media.

In fact, however, this type of common sense butts heads with the National Labor Relations Act, according to several decisions of the National Labor Relations Board.

Section 7 of the National Labor Relations Act proscribes restrictions on employee statements of complaint about working conditions for the purpose of “concerted activity:” organizing by employees to do something about those conditions.

The NLRB has issued several decisions holding that the termination of employees who violated rules against disparagement in social media was improper, some resulting in orders for back pay to the employee and, occasionally, payment of the worker’s legal fees, in addition to the costs of the company’s own counsel.

Although the NLRB doesn’t keep statistics on reinstatement cases based on challenges to firings for violating social media policies, a report from the board’s general counsel has called the issue a “hot topic.”

In one case cited in the report, the firing of an employee for comments on Facebook and violation of a firm’s “non-disparagement rule” on social media was found unlawful for being “overbroad.”

Certain social media policy restrictions won’t violate labor laws (posts that violate state or federal confidentiality laws, most harassing behavior, etc.), but guidance is required so that intuition of workplace common sense doesn’t ground the company on the rocks of federal labor law when it comes to social media ground rules.

Kenneth Rashbaum is an attorney and principal of New York-based Rashbaum Associates, specializing in social media compliance, policy and other legal issues; privacy, cyber-security and electronic information compliance, and litigation. The firm's web site is www.rashbaumassociates.com.

(2) Comments
When employees get fired due to any comment made on personal account in social media, it is not only overboard but also shows how impatient the employers are. Employers have to understand that employees can't be thrown away simply because he/she has made some comment in personal account because professional lives and personal lives are two separate parts of life. Until and unless the employee divulges any official document in the social media, employers have no right to sneak peek employees' lives. Derick from http://teletrade.bg/
Posted by Derick B | Thursday, November 28 2013 at 4:50PM ET
Both employers and employees need to respect rights and obligations of the other. Whilst the employee has the right to air his views on the social media, it is bound to have some repercussions at work. The sensible way would be to try and approach the senior and escalate the issue to the next higher level. Employers too need to have an open mind and ensure a mechanism for addressing complaints and suggestions.
Posted by KIMMY B | Sunday, December 01 2013 at 1:26PM ET
Post a Comment
You must be registered to post a comment.
Not Registered?
You must be registered to post a comment. Click here to register.
Already registered? Log in here
Please note you must now log in with your email address and password.
2014 Summer Reading List for Advisors

Current Issue

The July Issue is now online!


Industry Events

August 10, 2014 |

September 9, 2014 |

September 17, 2014 |

September 20, 2014 |

September 28, 2014 |

Already a subscriber? Log in here