The IRS ruled last week that it will recognize same-sex couples even if they reside in a state that does not recognize their marriage, provided they were lawfully married in a state that does. The decision was in the wake of the Supreme Courts recent DOMA decision, which had raised a number of tax issues.
The ruling that came out last Thursday said the IRS will treat same-sex married couples as married even if they live in a non-recognition state, said Marvin Kirsner, a shareholder in the tax department of Greenberg Traurig, LLP. Its analogous to a 1958 revenue ruling, which dealt with common-law marriages. The IRS said we recognize a marriage if it was the law of the state where the marriage arose. For federal income tax purposes, if you move to another state that doesnt recognize common-law marriage, we will still recognize it. Thats one of the bases of the current ruling.
The marriage must be an actual marriage that is valid in the state in which it took place. It does not apply to civil unions or registered domestic partnerships, Kirsner noted.
Moreover, the ruling is retroactive, so that lawfully married same-sex couples may use the ruling to file amended returns and apply for refunds, although they are not required to amend their returns if doing so would result in a greater tax liability. But going forward, they do not have the option to file as single.
Its not optional, Kirsner said. The IRS says that a same-sex married couple is married whether they want to be or not, even if some will end up owing more in taxes than if they were filing single . They have to file as married filing jointly or married filing separately.
There are still some unanswered issues, however. Of all the states that do not recognize same-sex marriage, 28 impose a state income tax of some form, which brings up questions, according to Kirsner.
Most state income tax regimes begin with federal taxable income as the starting point, Kirsner said. "So if a state does not recognize a same-sex marriage, it has to decide how it will handle a validly married same-sex couple that resides and owes tax in the state. If it has them file a joint state return, it will be tacitly recognizing the marriage.
Another way would be to have each spouse prepare a pro forma federal return as a single person and use the taxable income line on that as a starting point, he indicated.
The easiest and simplest way would be to simply allow a same-sex couple to file a joint state tax return, recognizing the marriage for tax purposes only, he said. But in many cases they will have to amend their current tax laws.