BofA Directors’ Merrill Lynch Accord Flawed, Objectors Argue

Bank of America Corp. directors’ $20 million settlement of investor lawsuits over the purchase of Merrill Lynch & Co. is inadequate given the billions of dollars of harm the deal caused, objectors to the accord said.

The proposed settlement amounts to 4 percent of the board’s $500 million of insurance coverage and less than 1 percent of the more than $2.4 billion Bank of America officials agreed to pay in September to resolve other investors’ securities-fraud claims over the Merrill Lynch deal, lawyers for the shareholders said in federal court filings in New York.

“The grossly inadequate $20 million value of the proposed settlement cannot be justified under any circumstances,” Paul Paradis, a New York-based lawyer for Bank of America investors who sued in Delaware, claiming the bank overpaid for Merrill Lynch, said in a filing yesterday. If the accord is approved, it could wipe out the Delaware claims.

A federal judge in Manhattan still must decide whether to approve Charlotte, North Carolina-based Bank of America’s $2.43 billion settlement of shareholder suits that claimed management hid Merrill losses ahead of the 2009 deal. The accord is separate from the $20 million settlement of so-called derivative claims against directors.

The shareholders claimed former Chief Executive Officer Kenneth D. Lewis and other board members misled them about the losses Merrill Lynch incurred before the $18.5 billion buyout and should have pulled the plug on the deal.

Lawrence Grayson, a Bank of America spokesman, declined to comment on the objection to the settlement.

‘Outstanding Settlement’

Lawyers for two pension funds backing the $20 million settlement contend that the accord forces Bank of America to make corporate-governance changes that will spark more accurate disclosures about acquisitions.

Plaintiffs “have achieved through good-faith, arms’-length negotiations an outstanding settlement that is in the best interests of Bank of America and its shareholders,” Albert Myers, a Louisiana-based lawyer for the funds, said in a Nov. 6 court filing.

New York-based Merrill Lynch, founded by Charles E. Merrill in 1914, had at least $50 billion in losses and writedowns linked to the collapse of the U.S. subprime mortgage market before agreeing to be sold.

‘Paying Twice’

Bank of America officials said in earlier court filings they acquired Merrill Lynch at the behest of government officials concerned about the investment firm’s subprime losses. The deal saddled the bank with losses and prompted regulators to provide $20 billion in bailout financing.

The filings in the shareholder suit against the directors include unsealed copies of internal e-mails from Brian Moynihan, Bank of America’s current CEO, indicating he was concerned the firm was overpaying for Merrill Lynch.

In a December 2008 e-mail, Moynihan complained the bank was “paying twice (so to speak) for Merrill once to ml shareholders and once to the govt by delivering them” shares. Moynihan was an executive overseeing the bank’s private equity and global operations units at the time, according to a Bloomberg Businessweek profile.

The filings also show that some Bank of America directors said they had heard colleagues lay the blame for the Merrill Lynch debacle at Lewis’s door.

‘Ken Ego’

William Barnet III, a South Carolina businessman who stepped down from Bank of America’s board in July 2009, said in an e-mail, “some feel Ken ego and ambition cause of all this,” in a reference to Lewis. The e-mail was sent to fellow director Chad Gifford in January of the same year. Gifford is still on the bank’s board, according to his Bloomberg profile.

Lewis, who as CEO spent more than $130 billion on takeovers, clashed with regulators including the Federal Reserve and then-Treasury Secretary Hank Paulson by trying to back out of the Merrill takeover over the brokerage firm’s deepening losses.

Lewis went ahead with the deal under pressure, only to be stripped of his chairman’s title later in 2009 amid a shareholder revolt. That September, he announced plans to step down by year’s end without a successor in place.

Andrew Ceresney, a New York-based lawyer who represents Lewis, didn’t immediately return a call for comment today on Barnet’s e-mail.

Legal Settlements

Moynihan, who took over in 2010, has approved more than $28 billion for settlements of legal and regulatory claims tied to his predecessor’s takeovers of Countrywide Financial Corp. and Merrill Lynch.

Anthony Saunders, a New York University finance professor hired by shareholders to assess Bank of America’s losses from the Merrill Lynch buyout, found the lender suffered at least $5.9 billion in damages from the deal.

Included in those damages was a $150 million settlement in 2010 with the U.S. Securities & Exchange Commission over executives’ misstatements about the Merrill Lynch purchase, Saunders said in his 50-page report.

Get access to this article and thousands more...

All Financial Planning articles are archived after 7 days. REGISTER NOW for unlimited access to all recently archived articles, as well as thousands of searchable stories. Registered Members also gain access to exclusive industry white paper downloads, web seminars, blog discussions, the iPad App, CE Exams, and conference discounts. Qualified members may also choose to receive our free monthly magazine and any of our daily or weekly e-newsletters covering the latest breaking news, opinions from industry leaders, developing trends and growth strategies.

Already Registered?

Comments (0)

Be the first to comment on this post using the section below.

Add Your Comments:
Not Registered?
You must be registered to post a comment. Click here to register.
Already registered? Log in here
Please note you must now log in with your email address and password.

Already a subscriber? Log in here