In what some in the industry are heralding as a backhanded acknowledgement of 12b-1 fees, the Securities and Exchange Commission is reportedly considering putting a cap on the controversial level-loads.


But as industry executives are wont to debate any restrictions on the fees, others are balking at the notion, arguing that the SEC should not put a limit on the fees, commonly charged on C Shares and paid to brokers and other salespeople. These naysayers contend that a cap on the fees would hurt mutual fund investors because other fees will increase as a result. Or, funds will have to scramble to impose conversions.


This is part of a new measure that the SEC is considering, Investment News reports. The second part would split the fees into administration and distribution, and sales costs.


Toward the beginning of his term, current SEC Director of the Division of Investment Management Andrew J. “Buddy” Donohue threatened to look into eliminating the fees altogether. That debate, if it has occurred at the SEC, has at least fallen off the radar for the past year.


As a result of the SEC’s renewed focus on merely adjusting, renaming or capping 12b-1 fees—rather than outright eliminating them—commented Morningstar Managing Director Don Phillips, the mutual fund industry “should be doing cartwheels.”


Depending on the fund complex, between 1% and 20% of assets under management are held in C Share classes that charge 12b-1 fees. Some firms’ C Shares convert to F Shares or other share classes that forgive the level loads after, say, 10 years.


Thus, some dissonant voices in the industry argue that the whole 12b-1 fee argument is no longer as big a deal as it once was. “At the end of the day,” said Sam Campbell, director of research for Financial Research Corp., “C Shares are not in decline, but, certainly, as a percentage of [fund groups’] overall business, they aren’t huge.”

Subscribe Now

Access to premium content including in-depth coverage of mutual funds, hedge funds, 401(K)s, 529 plans, and more.

3-Week Free Trial

Insight and analysis into the management, marketing, operations and technology of the asset management industry.