Infinite QE is destroying traditional bond fund strategies
In a matter of weeks, bond investors have seen some of their firmest market convictions swept away in a massive confluence of government stimulus and central bank intervention. Now, they’re being forced to rework their strategies for a new era.
Core tenets such as what constitutes a safe asset, the value of bonds as a portfolio hedge, and expectations for returns over the next decade are all being reconsidered as governments and central banks strive to avert a global depression.
Underlying much of the uncertainty is the risk that trillions of dollars in monetary and fiscal stimulus could create an eventual inflation shock that will trigger losses for bondholders.
“I’ve never, ever, ever seen anything like this before,” said Nader Naeimi, head of dynamic markets at AMP Capital Investors in Sydney. “You have enormous buyers of debt meeting massive coordinated fiscal stimulus by governments across the globe. For bond investors, you’re caught between a rock and a hard place.”
QE KILLS VALUATION MODELS
While past quantitative easing programs have led to similar concerns, this emergency response is different because it’s playing out in weeks rather than months and limits on QE bond purchases have quickly been scrapped.
Fed Chairman Jerome Powell said Thursday the central bank will maintain its efforts “aggressively and forthrightly.” In an interview on NBC’s “Today” show, he said the Fed will not “run out of ammunition” after promising unlimited bond purchases. His comments came hours after the European Central Bank scrapped most of the bond-buying limits in its own program.
In need-for-speed markets lashed by the spreading coronavirus, this breed of rules-based trading is paying off.March 23
COVID-19 is bringing business to PayPal, Blend, Symphony and others as homebound consumers and commercial clients seek more electronic services. But demand could cool if the economy slows further.March 18
The firm is snapping up five- and 10-year notes as it predicts slowing inflation and trade tensions will push the Fed to lower its benchmark 75 basis points.July 5
While this type of policy dominates markets, strategic thinking is stymied and some prized investment tools appear to be defunct, said Ronald van Steenweghen of Degroof Petercam Asset Management.
“Valuation models, correlation, mean reversion and other things we rely on fail in these circumstances,” said the Brussels-based money manager. “Liquidity is also very poor so it is difficult to be super-agile.”
Ordinarily, the prospect of a multi-trillion-dollar government spending surge globally ought to send borrowing costs soaring. But central bank purchases are now reshaping rates markets — emulating the Bank of Japan’s yield-curve control policy starting in 2016 — and quashing these latest volatility spikes.
Investors shouldn’t expect to see much more than moderately steep yield curves, since the Fed and its peers don’t want higher benchmark borrowing costs to undermine their stimulus, says Scott Thiel, fixed income strategist at BlackRock.
“That would be detrimental to financial conditions and to the ability for the stimulus to feed through to the economy,” Thiel said. “So the short answer is, it’s yield-curve control.”
Looking further out, money managers need to reassess another assumption that’s become widely held in recent years: that inflation is dead. Van Steenweghen says he’s interested in inflation-linked bonds, though timing a foray into that market is “tricky.”
Naeimi also said he expects that the coordination by central banks and governments will spike inflation at some stage. “It all adds to the volatility of holding bonds,” he said. But for the time being, he’s range-trading Australian bonds — buying when 10-year yields hit 1.5%, and selling at 0.6%.
Many market veterans agree that faster inflation may return in a recovery awash with stimulus that central banks and governments may find tough to withdraw. A reassessment of consumer-price expectations would be a major setback for expensive risk-free bonds, especially those with the longest maturities, which are most vulnerable to inflation eroding their value over time.
At the moment that’s hard to envisage, as the market sees the U.S. consumer price index climbing by barely 1% over the next decade. And similar predictions proved wrong when central banks piled into asset purchases after the last recession. Still, central bank balance sheets are set to explode further into uncharted territory.
“There’s tension in all of this,” said Hamish Pepper, fixed-income and currency strategist at Harbour Asset Management in Wellington, New Zealand. “I don’t think it’s necessarily about waking up one morning realizing that bond yields should be 100 basis points higher from here — but you have to think about inflation at some point.”
HAVEN OR NOT?
This has led to another core conviction being revised in some quarters: the efficacy of U.S. Treasurys as a safe haven and portfolio hedge. Mark Holman, chief executive and founding partner of TwentyFour Asset Management in London, started questioning that when the 10-year benchmark hit its historic low early this month.
“Will government bonds play the same role in your portfolio going forward as they have in the past?” he said. “To me the answer is no they don’t — I’d rather own cash.”
He’s turning to high-quality corporate credit for low-risk income, particularly in the longer maturity bonds gradually rallying back from a plunge. He sees no chance of central banks escaping the zero-bound’s gravitational pull in the foreseeable future.
“What we do know is we’re going to have zero rates around the world for another decade, and we’re going to have the need for income for another decade,” he said.
It’s clear to many money managers that the current volatility has created opportunities in the longer term, with funding stress and liquidity problems distorting valuations. For Sonal Desai, chief investment officer at Franklin Templeton Fixed Income, the remaining question is choosing the right time to enter, a task she thinks is impossible to get totally right.
“Clearly the current market dislocation throws out opportunities,” she said. “The unwinding of leverage in the muni market is exposing some attractive fundamental value, and I expect we will see the same in the mortgage space.”
The first challenge for investors, though, is simply to find their bearings in a crisis without recent historical parallel.
“It’s very hard to look at this in a historical context and then apply an investment framework around it,” said BlackRock’s Thiel. “The most applicable period is right before America entered WW2, when you had gigantic stimulus to spur the war effort. I mean, Ford made bombers in WW2 and now they’re making ventilators in 2020.”