Worst-performing small-cap funds of the decade

The 20 worst-performing small-cap funds of the last 10 years, nearly all of which are value strategy funds, had an average return of roughly 6.7%, Morningstar Direct data show. So far this year, the same funds have a loss of more than 5%.

Pitted against the broader industry, this lineup of mutual funds and ETFs have underperformed. For comparison, index trackers such as the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY) and the SPDR Dow Jones Industrial Average ETF Trust (DIA) delivered 10-year gains of 13.76% and 12.75%, respectively, over the same period. Year-to-date, SPY and DIA have gains of 12.29% and 5.21%.

In bonds, the iShares Core U.S. Aggregate Bond ETF (AGG) had gains of 6.86% and 3.62% over the YTD and 10-year periods.

“There are numerous arguments about why value has underperformed growth for so long, but at least one reason has to do with sector concentrations,” says Matt Kerr, senior wealth advisor at Keel Point. “Value indexes tend to have a large allocation to financials and energy, whereas growth indexes tend to be overweight the technology sector.”

Much like the small-cap category’s top-performers, funds here carry fees well above the broader industry. With an average net expense ratio of 111 basis points, the worst-performing small-cap funds were more than twice that of the 0.45% investors paid last year, according to Morningstar’s most recent annual fee survey.

“The relative performance of individual asset classes and investment styles will move in and out of favor over time,” Kerr says. “While it can make sense to tilt your portfolio in a certain direction, predicting the precise turning points in these cycles is profoundly difficult. That’s why it is often better to focus on building a well-diversified portfolio with exposures to a variety of sources of long-term returns.”

Scroll through to see the 20 small-cap mutual funds and ETFs with the worst 10-year returns through Nov. 19. Funds with less than $100 million in AUM were excluded, as were funds with investment minimums above $100,000, leveraged and institutional funds. Assets and expense ratios, as well as YTD, one-, three- and five- returns are also listed for each. The data show each fund's primary share class. All data is from Morningstar Direct.

FP112320_20 copy.png

Aegis Value I (AVALX)

1-Yr. Return: 24.6%
3-Yr. Annualized Return: 5.98%
5-Yr. Annualized Return: 14.55%
FP112320_19 copy.png

JHancock Small Cap Value NAV (JSCNX)

1-Yr. Return: -11%
3-Yr. Annualized Return: -0.75%
5-Yr. Annualized Return: 3.23%
FP112320_18 copy.png

iShares Morningstar Small-Cap Value ETF (JKL)

1-Yr. Return: -4.23%
3-Yr. Annualized Return: -1.4%
5-Yr. Annualized Return: 4.05%
FP112320_17 copy.png

FPA Queens Road Small Cap Value (QRSVX)

1-Yr. Return: 7.79%
3-Yr. Annualized Return: 6.87%
5-Yr. Annualized Return: 7.5%
FP112320_16 copy.png

Franklin MicroCap Value A (FRMCX)

1-Yr. Return: -0.39%
3-Yr. Annualized Return: -1.44%
5-Yr. Annualized Return: 5.18%
Front Load: 5.5%
FP112320_15 copy.png

Royce Special Equity Investment (RYSEX)

1-Yr. Return: 5.25%
3-Yr. Annualized Return: 1.99%
5-Yr. Annualized Return: 7.18%
Redemption Load: 1%
FP112320_14 copy.png

Putnam Small Cap Value A (PSLAX)

1-Yr. Return: -3.14%
3-Yr. Annualized Return: -1.21%
5-Yr. Annualized Return: 3.93%
Front Load: 5.75%
FP112320_13 copy.png

VALIC Company II Small Cap Value (VCSVX)

1-Yr. Return: -1.29%
3-Yr. Annualized Return: -0.43%
5-Yr. Annualized Return: 4.75%
FP112320_12 copy.png

Diamond Hill Small Cap I (DHSIX)

1-Yr. Return: -2.33%
3-Yr. Annualized Return: 0.54%
5-Yr. Annualized Return: 3.64%
FP112320_11 copy.png

Delaware Special Situations A (FISSX)

1-Yr. Return: -6.77%
3-Yr. Annualized Return: -2.78%
5-Yr. Annualized Return: 3.38%
Front Load: 5.75%
FP112320_10 copy.png

Invesco S&P SmallCap 600 Pure Value ETF (RZV)

1-Yr. Return: -6.43%
3-Yr. Annualized Return: -3.04%
5-Yr. Annualized Return: 2.56%
FP112320_09 copy.png

Heartland Value Plus Investor (HRVIX)

1-Yr. Return: 6.69%
3-Yr. Annualized Return: 4.94%
5-Yr. Annualized Return: 7.74%
Redemption Load: 2%
FP112320_08 copy.png

SEI Small Cap Value F (SIMT) (SESVX)

1-Yr. Return: -3.67%
3-Yr. Annualized Return: -1.2%
5-Yr. Annualized Return: 3.33%
FP112320_07 copy.png

Heartland Value Investor (HRTVX)

1-Yr. Return: 7.02%
3-Yr. Annualized Return: 2.65%
5-Yr. Annualized Return: 6.06%
Redemption Load: 2%
FP112320_06 copy.png

Mutual of America Small Cap Value (MAVKX)

1-Yr. Return: -9.14%
3-Yr. Annualized Return: -2.99%
5-Yr. Annualized Return: 2.42%
FP112320_05 copy.png

AllianzGI Small-Cap Value A (PCVAX)

1-Yr. Return: -7.45%
3-Yr. Annualized Return: -2.51%
5-Yr. Annualized Return: 3.27%
Front Load: 5.5%
FP112320_04 copy.png

ClearBridge Small Cap Value A (SBVAX)

1-Yr. Return: -6.68%
3-Yr. Annualized Return: -2.82%
5-Yr. Annualized Return: 2.95%
Front Load: 5.75%
FP112320_03 copy.png

Royce Micro-Cap Investment (RYOTX)

1-Yr. Return: 16.11%
3-Yr. Annualized Return: 7.1%
5-Yr. Annualized Return: 8.66%
Redemption Load: 1%
FP112320_02 copy.png

Tocqueville Phoenix Fund (TOPHX)

1-Yr. Return: -0.74%
3-Yr. Annualized Return: -0.32%
5-Yr. Annualized Return: 3.8%
FP112320_01 copy.png

Royce Small-Cap Value Service (RYVFX)

1-Yr. Return: -10.97%
3-Yr. Annualized Return: -0.57%
5-Yr. Annualized Return: 3.3%
Redemption Load: 1%
MORE FROM FINANCIAL PLANNING