Smart beta takes on $3.8T muni market
First smart beta investing took stocks by storm. Then it moved to bonds. Now it’s making its way to the $3.8 trillion market for U.S. municipal debt.
Columbia Threadneedle Investments, known for its muni bond mutual funds, has filed for an ETF called the Columbia Multi-Sector Municipal Income ETF (CATRX), which will seek to replicate the performance of a muni market index with a “rules-based” and “strategic beta” approach, according to a May filing with the SEC.
Once it starts trading, it’ll be Columbia’s first muni bond ETF and likely one of the first smart beta funds in the muni market. Smart beta is a strategy that aims to give investors more targeted exposure by building indexes around themes, called factors, such as momentum or value.
ETFs haven’t made deep inroads in the muni bond market like they have in other asset classes, with just over 40 muni funds trading. Still, Columbia found in a survey of more than 100 financial advisors that over half would consider buying a smart beta muni bond ETF for clients.
The results are “encouraging,” Marc Zeitoun, head of strategic beta at Columbia Threadneedle, said in an interview. He estimates the shift to benchmarking and passive investing in munis is about six years behind the equity market.
“This is a trend that will likely occur in the municipal world,” Zeitoun said. “It’s happening in every other asset class.”
A long-term approach to owning individual bonds is rewarded with both greater yield and safety.September 5
Forget bond ladders. Laddering defined-maturity exchange traded funds may be a safer fixed-income strategy for clients.September 1
Portfolio managers say taxable alternatives have appeared cheaper lately when compared to the short end of the tax-exempt yield curve.August 28
Muni ETFs typically use traditional passive investing strategies. For example, BlackRock’s $10 billion iShares National Muni Bond ETF (MUB) follows the performance of a market-value weighted index, meaning it carries high exposures to the states and sectors with the largest amounts of debt outstanding, like California and New York.
The Columbia fund would take a different approach, targeting debt market factors such as yield, quality, maturity, liquidity and interest rate sensitivity, according to the filing. The ETF also would establish “rules” for what it won’t buy, like California bonds, which have gotten increasingly expensive as people look to shield their income from taxes.
Similarly, while the fund will have some exposure to junk-rated munis, it’s taking a careful approach to those securities. The ETF won’t have tobacco bonds as part of its high-yield holdings because they risk default if Americans keep quitting smoking. And it won’t buy notes sold by bankrupt Puerto Rico or other U.S. territories that are all facing high debt levels.
About 45% of the fund will be in “core” revenue bonds that are rated Aa3 or lower, 20% will be in health-care munis rated Aa2 or lower, 15% will be in revenue bonds rated Aa2 or higher, 10% will be in general-obligation bonds rated Aa3 or higher and another 10% will be in high-yield munis, according to the filing says. Each sector carries different maturity requirements.
Catherine Stienstra, head of muni bond investments at Columbia, is listed as the lead portfolio manager for the Columbia Multi-Sector Municipal Income ETF.
The high exposure to revenue bonds jibes with a widespread preference among muni bond investors for debt backed by a revenue stream as opposed to a promise to pay, known as general-obligation bonds. This comes after Detroit’s bankruptcy imposed losses on general-obligation bondholders, eroding the value of a pledge once considered sacrosanct.
Indexing has been slow to catch on in the muni market because investors believe it’s difficult to navigate and therefore are willing to pay for actively-managed portfolios, said Todd Rosenbluth, director of ETF and mutual fund research at CFRA Research. The Columbia fund could be appealing because its smart beta approach would screen for investments based on characteristics that active managers use, he said.
“It’s a great marriage of what’s working in both the active world and in the index world,” Rosenbluth said.
One concern advisors have surrounding smart beta fixed-income funds is the cost, Columbia found in its survey. The ETF filing does not yet disclose the fund’s proposed fees. Rosenbluth said the costs will likely be cheaper than actively-managed alternatives. He expects smart beta to catch on in the muni market — just like equities and taxable fixed-income products — especially if the Columbia fund can gather assets quickly.
“It’s evolutionary that we see this happening in the muni bond ETF space,” he said.