Vanguard, Nuveen, Goldman win fight for cash flooding muni funds
A handful of the biggest firms on Wall Street are landing the vast majority of cash pouring into the municipal-bond market.
Vanguard’s mutual funds focused on tax-exempt debt have received about $12.7 billion this year, or nearly a third of the $39.1 billion that’s been added to such funds, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. TIAA’s Nuveen, Goldman Sachs, BlackRock and MacKay Shields received another $18.2 billion, leaving those five companies with about 80% of the new cash.
The figures show that the biggest Wall Street firms are benefiting the most from the rush this year into municipal bonds, illustrating the difficulty that smaller companies may have in keeping up with industry behemoths that have widespread brand recognition and the ability to charge lower fees.
"It’s the Amazon effect in the municipal market," said Tom Doe, president of Municipal Market Analytics, an advisory firm. "If you’re the number one performer that doesn’t necessarily correlate with an increase in assets. It’s not a performance vehicle, it’s branding and costs."
Higher-income Americans have poured cash into municipal mutual funds this year as the federal limit on state and local tax deductions leaves some looking for new ways to drive down what they owe. Such funds have attracted new investments every week since early January, leaving them on pace for a potentially record-setting year.
The firm has parted ways with its CEO Alex Friedman and launched a restructuring plan.November 26
Investors in higher-beta credit funds are shunning longer-duration debt following recent equity turmoil.February 15
That’s coming just as the business is showing signs of becoming increasingly concentrated. In October, Pimco agreed to buy Gurtin Municipal Bond Management, a specialist overseeing about $12 billion of the securities for high-net-worth investors. That same month, Invesco announced the acquisition of OppenheimerFunds, given the combined firm a major share of the municipal junk-bond market.
Doe said that the industry’s concentration could make a retreat from the municipal market more problematic if it forced the major firms to sell at the same time in order to meet investor redemptions.
"In any market if everyone is investing in a similar way, if you don’t have a diversity of participants, you are vulnerable to disruption and less liquidity," he said.
While it makes sense that some of the biggest firms are pulling in the most cash, their share of this year’s inflows is bigger than their overall share of the industry’s assets, indicating expanding leads over rivals. For example, Vanguard, which accounts for about 23% of municipal mutual fund assets, received about 32% of the year’s new investments. Nuveen pulled in 16%, double its market share.
"I think you’ve got very established muni teams and which have been gathering assets and managing them successfully for quite sometime," said Beth Foos, an analyst with Morningstar Inc. "Folks may have a little bit more confidence in those large teams that could do that bottom up research to find some dislocation in the muni market when spreads are this tight."
J.R. Rieger, author of trade newsletter the Rieger Report, said the concentration is part of a broader trend across other investment classes, including Treasuries and corporate bonds.
"You see a migration to lower cost funds at bigger firms versus the higher manager fees for active managed portfolios," he said. — Additional reporting by William Spada