Vanguard trounces BlackRock for ETF flows in volatile first half

Register now

Vanguard’s U.S. ETFs attracted inflows of about $89 billion in the first half, surging ahead of industry leader BlackRock in a volatile period.

BlackRock took in an estimated $38 billion, according to Bloomberg Intelligence data, as market swings fueled by the coronavirus crisis spurred selling from the types of active traders who favor the iShares lineup. Vanguard’s dominance contrasts with the first half of 2019, when BlackRock led its main rival by about $1.9 billion.

“Vanguard is more focused on these types of products which are designed to cater to long-term, buy-and-hold investors,” said Alex Bryan, director of passive strategies and research for North America at Morningstar. Such customers “likely aren’t looking to make tactical adjustments based on what’s going on in the market,” he said.

The flows strike a blow for Vanguard in the increasingly fierce battle to dominate a more than $4 trillion market. BlackRock became the fund industry leader with its acquisition of the iShares lineup more than a decade ago, but Bloomberg Intelligence analysts estimate it could be overtaken in size by its chief competitor within 10 years — or faster in an extended downturn.

As asset managers launch funds with this new structure, lack of familiarity may hinder advisors’ adoption of them.
June 12
3 Min Read
In the months since CEO Larry Fink’s push to focus the firm’s efforts on ESG, the investing landscape has changed more than anyone could have anticipated.
June 8
7 Min Read

BlackRock said market upheaval underscores the value of its lineup.

“When investors needed to rapidly reposition their equity portfolios in light of economic uncertainty and record volatility, they turned to iShares,” said Ed Sweeney, a spokesman for the New York-based firm. “The same is true when they needed liquidity and transparency in fixed-income markets. IShares’ ETFs repeatedly demonstrated their versatility and resilience this year.”

A “distribution bump” from the commission-free trading trend that took hold late last year also may be benefiting Vanguard, Bloomberg Intelligence analysts wrote last month. The index-investing pioneer, known for its low costs, tends to win whenever it gets on an even playing field, according to the report.

BlackRock’s annual U.S. ETF flows were greater than Vanguard’s from 2014 through 2019, according to Bloomberg data. It still reigns in assets, with iShares accounting for about 38% of the U.S. ETF market, compared with 27% for Vanguard’s offerings.

And it hasn’t taken the fight for customers sitting down. The firm lowered fees on three U.S. equity ETFs in June. That included reducing what it charges for its largest such product, the iShares Core S&P 500 ETF, to 3 cents per $100 invested from 4 cents. The key differentiator for broad market-tracking products such as the Core S&P 500 ETF can often be fees, Bryan said.

Vanguard’s ETF cash flow this year is “a testament to our investors’ resolve,” said Rich Powers, head of ETF product management at the Malvern, Pennsylvania-based firm.

20 biggest U.S. fund families post $65B in outflows in the year of coronavirus
Here's how the largest groups have fared during unprecedented market activity.

“They’ve maintained discipline, continuing to work towards savings goals in the face of extreme market volatility,” Powers said. Demand has increased from “all types of investors, but particularly by financial advisors that prefer a low-cost, broadly diversified portfolio with intraday liquidity and tight spreads.”

But Vanguard’s ETF inflows were coupled with outflows from its long-term mutual funds. Driven by withdrawals during the market swoon in March, the funds had more than $20 billion in net redemptions this year through May.

Vanguard structures its ETFs as an arm of its mutual funds, a format it patented. The firm’s ETF lineup may be poised to see another bump in the near future. Vanguard plans to convert some mutual fund holdings to lower-cost ETF shares for clients of its advisory business, spokesman Freddy Martino confirmed. — Additional reporting by Dan Reichl

Bloomberg News
ETFs Fund performance Vanguard BlackRock iShares Asset managers Money Management Executive
MORE FROM FINANCIAL PLANNING